Who Owns Our Kids Anyway?

On Valentine’s Day 2013, the Massachusetts Department of Children and Families took into emergency custody then-14-year-old Justina Pelletier because the doctors at Tufts Medical Center and doctors at Boston Children’s Hospital collided over the diagnosis of her rare medical condition. But when medical egos and battles lead to a child’s being torn from her parents by judges ruling on dubious grounds, isn’t it time to confess that something is seriously askew in society and even under the stethoscope?

Fox News recently summarized the 15-month custody catastrophe by explaining that Tufts was originally treating Justina for a rare mitochondrial disease affecting cellular energy production. When gastrointestinal problems complicated her ailments, Tufts’ doctors referred her to Boston Children’s Hospital. But those doctors diagnosed her instead with somatoform disorder — a psychological condition that has no known physical origin.

Justina’s parents immediately rejected the new psychiatric diagnosis and let their grievances be known to the Boston Children’s Hospital personnel. But rather than console and work with the parents, the staff called in the state, which in turn accused the parents of medical child abuse.

Justina was held captive for nearly a year in a psychiatric ward for children before being transported to a Wayside Youth & Family Support Network facility. In March, a juvenile court judge reprimanded the parents for verbal assault and abuse. But Justina’s parents cried foul, claiming the judge ignored Tufts’ standing medical testimony that their daughter’s diagnosis was in fact mitochondrial disease.

Fox News further reported this past week that after being held for 15 months by the commonwealth of Massachusetts, Justina was moved to a facility in her own state of Connecticut. Ironically, that transfer came a day after her family was denied a visit with her in the previous facility on Mother’s Day.

Justina’s father told Fox News that the new facility is “only 15 minutes closer” than the Massachusetts complex, and that it was “just a lateral move.” Her parents went on to say the move was “not at all meant as a step toward regaining custody,” which a judge will ultimately decide. They called the whole hospital-state fiasco with their child “barbaric.”

Since the whole custody tragedy began, Justina’s parents have been granted only hourly visits each week. And throughout it all, Justina hasn’t attended school or church and, most heartbreaking of all, has been kept from the security, safety, and loving warmth of her own family, home, and bed. Is it any wonder why her condition continues to deteriorate?

All Justina’s parents want now is for the commonwealth of Massachusetts to allow their beloved child to finally come home and celebrate her 16th birthday on May 24. Isn’t that the least that state officials could do, especially after all the family has been through?

My friend Mike Huckabee stated it well back in March: “What a shame when the government thinks that it knows better (how) to take care of the medical treatment of the daughter than the mother and the father do.”

Huckabee added, “There’s something wrong when a government kidnaps children from their own families.” And I would add that there is something equally wrong when a situation such as this prompts millions of other parents across the country to become paranoid about taking their child to the hospital for fear that a misdiagnosis could lead to the child’s abduction by the state.

Pages: 1 2

The views expressed in this opinion article are solely those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by WesternJournalism.com.

This post originally appeared on Western Journalism – Informing And Equipping Americans Who Love Freedom

"Loophole" from Obama's IRS: Protect your IRA or 401(k) with gold and silver... click here to get a NO-COST Info Guide >


  1. MuslimLuvChrist says:

    My kids are the cutest little monsters you’ve ever seen, now for instance you take my kids, please. They are so much like animals that now I know why tigers eat their young

  2. Edwardkoziol says:

    In the Justina Peletier case I the gonernor Patrickof Mass thought he did and now it's coming around to bite him on his black ass. I wonder if Justina was black if any of this would have happened.All these bleeding heart people don't want mexican families split up but if your white watch out. The illegals got a choice they all can go back to Mexico and live as one big hapy famalia.

    • Are you trying to start a race war? Most likely, all you all care about is white people, white Americans, and conservative Americans…..

      • Edwardkoziol says:

        Daniel I don't have to start a race war your president and the rodents that back him are doing a good job.People like Holder ,Waters., Clyburn the Clintons.Not that it's any of your business but I've been backing Dr.Ben Carson for a true black president not some dummy that has to read or hear it on TV to know what is happening in the country.

Speak Your Mind