New Information Could Lead To Death Penalty For Bowe Bergdahl

With all the peripheral confusion surrounding the exchange of five terror suspects for the return of U.S. Army Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl, the national conversation inevitably includes widespread accusations the prisoner of war was in reality a deserter who hated his own country and its military.

Starting with an email he sent his parents in the days before he went missing, Bergdahl’s story is packed with evidence that he had no intention of remaining loyal to America in Afghanistan. His fellow soldiers report that, just before he left his platoon, he got rid of personal items and left behind his military equipment along with a note explaining his desertion.

Nevertheless, reports indicate a search and rescue mission ensued that led to the death of as many as eight individuals.

Do you think Bergdahl should face a court martial for allegations that he deserted his fellow soldiers? Click here to weigh in on our important new poll!

The Associated Press reported that even the Pentagon recognized Bergdahl left the base on his own accord as far back as 2010.

Now that he is home, the Obama administration seems determined to protect his reputation as much as possible. For some military experts, however, it appears Bergdahl’s troubles are far from over.

Victor Hansen, who has served as both a military prosecutor and defense lawyer, said a court martial is a distinct possibility for someone facing such allegations.

“Death is still a lawful sentence for desertion in a time of war,” he said.

Short of that sentence, he continued, “there could be significant punishment, significant confinement.”

Though there are only two cases of a soldier being executed for desertion in about the past 150 years, former military attorney and judge Lisa Schenck said Bergdahl could face charges related to both types of desertion recognized by the military. The first, she explained, results from a soldier’s intention to permanently leave his post; and the second involves leaving to avoid hazardous conditions.

She said some of the aspects necessary to prove his intent – especially considering the five years of captivity since his alleged desertion – could be hard to prove.

“That doesn’t mean he’s going to get an honorable discharge,” she explained.

Hansen, however, noted that it could be quite easy for Bergdahl to claim his intention was simply to leave the base for a short time. Without a written confession, he explained, assertions to the contrary will likely be considered circumstantial.

As the New York Times reported Tuesday, such a written confession might exist. The article states Bergdahl left behind a note explaining that he had grown disillusioned with the military, no longer supported his mission, and intended to leave permanently to begin a new life away from his fellow soldiers.

Hansen concluded the administration seems to have already established its preferred narrative.

“Since these pronouncements have been made and the president has said he’s a prisoner of war and all that stuff,” he said, “the subtle message here – or maybe not-so-subtle message – is that we don’t want anything to happen to this guy.”

Richard Rosen, who served as the U.S. Army’s Judge Advocate General’s School’s commandant, said he feels securing capital charges against Bergdahl is a long shot.

In all likelihood, he said, any charges would be noncapital; “and the maximum punishment is five years, a dishonorable discharge, and forfeiture of pay.”

What Do You Think? Take The Poll

  • For your submission to count, you must enter a valid email address. Western Journalism takes your privacy very seriously. We will never share your email address with anyone. Privacy Policy

    By voting in this poll, I understand that I will be eligible to receive free email updates and news from I can unsubscribe at any time at the bottom of each email.

This post originally appeared on Western Journalism – Informing And Equipping Americans Who Love Freedom

"Loophole" from Obama's IRS: Protect your IRA or 401(k) with gold and silver... click here to get a NO-COST Info Guide >


  1. Arrest him NOW and put him in a secure brig

  2. scholar says:

    Bergdahl deserves the death penalty. And so does Obama for what he did.

    • RacerJim says:

      And so does Hilary Clinton for what she didn't do re Benghazi.

      • Edwardkoziol says:

        Racer your right about Hitlary like Slick Willy didn't do in Mogadishu when he could have sent a gunship over to help those Blackhawk down soldiers.Talk about leaving no real American soldier behind.I can't believe Idaho would want to honor a rat.

  3. Edwardkoziol says:

    I hate to say this because I believe he is a rotten deserter and deserves the death penalty along with his father.But Obutthole will see to it that nothing happens to this dickwad.That Gen.Dempsey who served with Grant during the civil war is now brain dead when you listen to him talk.He wasn't worth trading a taliban janitor for him,he should have rotted over inFlintstone land.

Speak Your Mind